September 23rd, 2015: I’m in the preshow of MuppetVision 3D at Disney’s Hollywood Studios as we watch Sam the Eagle hilariously being trampled by a barrage of Muppets making their way onto the stage. Wobbling he begs, “Will somebody please take over?” before fainting.
A spotlight hits a perky cast member grappling her intercom, “Thanks, Sam, I’ve got it from here.” She turns her attention to the packed house, “Are you guys excited?!” A small round of cheers are elicited from the tired heat-stricken crowd. “Awesome!” she continues, “Well I’m equally as excited for you guys to check out Muppet Vision, speaking of Muppets, did anybody catch the premiere of their brand-new show last night?!”
This time you could hear a pin drop, as an awkward moment rolls over everybody as if we all forgot to do our homework. Ever the professional, the cast member brushes it off and launches straight into the safety spiel. Granted, everybody in the audience, including me, we’re most likely on a Walt Disney World vacation and did not care for whatever primetime programming launched the previous night. Yet this did not bode well considering the resort was absolutely caked in promotion for ABC’s brand-new highly-anticipated series.
That premonition turned out to be correct.
In early 2015, it was rumored that Bill Prady, co-creator of “The Big Bang Theory” and former Muppet writer along with Bob Kushell, a veteran television writer, were teaming up to bring back “The Muppet Show” for primetime after “Muppets Most Wanted” failed to light up the box office the previous year.
Social media was buzzing with nostalgia that the sketch show was returning before a confirmation that this was actually a sitcom. Not only a sitcom but a mockumentary in the vein of “The Office”. A 10-minute pitch reel gleefully poking fun at the entire concept was released to acclaim. It was witty, smart, and presented something new while not sacrificing the overall tone of the characters.
It then entered production, and something interesting happened. Prady found himself overwhelmed by his showrunner duties on Big Bang and gave more creative control over to Kushell. Did I mention Prady was the one who had an original connection with the Muppets, even writing the aforementioned MuppetVision 3D?
Kushell’s vision was a raw, snarky and cynical behind-the-scenes glimpse of the characters now banding together to produce a late-night talk show starring Miss Piggy. Under the idea that the group merely just did a bunch of projects together, they were less friends and more dysfunctional coworkers. Oh yeah, and they have adult problems such as hangovers, racism, and sex.
While this may remind you of many adult Muppet parodies such as the musical “Avenue Q”, the show was still bounded by a primetime censor. Thankfully, we aren’t treated to any nude puppets, but that still doesn’t stop Kermit the Frog from being a jerk, Miss Piggy from bedroom talk with Josh Groban and Fozzie dealing with the harsh realities of being a bear in a humans’ world.
Kushell and Prady stressed that this was mostly bending to the will of parodying today’s contemporary media, just as Henson would’ve done. In the lead-up to the show’s premiere, a fake presser was sent out to various entertainment rags about how (gasp!) Kermit the Frog and Miss Piggy have officially broken up. The tongue-in-fly promotion was done to set up the first season’s “will-they, won’t-they” romantic tension between the pair as Kermit lands a new swine girlfriend, Denise. As the frog puts it, “what can I say? I’m attracted to pigs.”
The love triangle was one of many elements meant to mirror NBC’s “The Office”, which had ended two years prior. In this case, it was shifting the Jim/Pam dynamic over to the Michael Scott character, this time played by Kermit. Michael was much more myopic and selfish than Kermit has ever been, so slight tweaks were made in his character, the executive producer of “Up Late with Miss Piggy”. It’s not so easy bein green, and by god, he’s finally going to show it.
Miss Piggy is dialed from selfish diva to absolute terror as a talk show host, a generally mean and callous presence with fierce disdain for her fellow staff. That staff, of course, still being those who worked with her in countless television series and feature-length films. Fozzie is the announcer, made to be daft but not always lovable as he makes bewilderingly unsympathetic decisions such as stealing souvenirs from his idol’s home and telling shockingly private and cruel jokes about his girlfriend.
Gonzo largely dodges the misanthropy machine by being transformed into a sadsack writer alongside Pepe and Rizzo, fellow slackers. One of the rare character dynamics that actually work, but sadly underused.
In the pilot, “Pig Girls Don’t Cry”, Kermit spends the episode enraged that Miss Piggy refuses to have Elizabeth Banks (in a nod to the original variety show, each episode would feature at least one guest star) as a guest while Fozzie finds out that his human girlfriend Becky’s parents are not fond of him because of, well their racism towards bears.
The next episode “Hostile Makeover” features Kermit setting Miss Piggy up with Josh Groban. A plethora of uncomfortable jokes are made about the famed singer “slicing bacon”, and generally made nearly every viewer wince. While to say The Muppets are strictly for kids would be a lie, but resorting to cheap, lazy, and grotesque adult humor was a tone whiplash many were not prepared for.
In the series’ fourth episode, “Pig Out”, Piggy invites herself to an after-work party resulting in hangovers for the crew. It’s insinuated that Beaker and Dr. Bunsen Honeydew may have had a drunken tryst. (“If it happens out of work, they don’t need to know about it!”) In a particularly bizarre development, a running thread is introduced in which Sam the Eagle harbors an intense crush on Janice, the lead guitar player for the Electric Mayhem. When Ed Helms crashes in, he swoops in and romances Janice while Sam seethes with jealousy.
There’s a joke in there somewhere about opposites attracting, in that Sam, the most uptight Muppet ever (he’s the standards and practices liaison for the talk show) being madly in love with Janice, quite possibly the most laid back Muppet ever, but nothing ever quite connects. Instead, the writing is heavily aping the same tropes of unrequited office romance slowly burning in other sitcoms, again, much like “The Office”. There’s no commentary or subversion, it just is.
This is where one of the series’ main problems seems to hit home, beyond even the distressing adult edge: the writers think they’re doing what the Muppets have done before, yet they don’t actually know why that worked. In “The Great Muppet Caper”, a brilliantly funny scene occurs when Kermit breaks character to tell Piggy she’s overacting. The two squabble, apologize and then return to the plot. Henson and his crew are winking at us, exposing the frame of dramatic tension. Kermit is not actually upset that Piggy impersonated Lady Holiday, he’s just acting!
Whereas by setting “The Muppets” as an edgy behind-the-scenes documentary set in a very real world, we have nothing to assume but these are the real actions of the characters themselves. There’s no actual parody occurring because nobody is winking at us about it. Heck, the fake tabloid press release doubles down on this premise. Kermit really is awkwardly skirting around his romance with Piggy, Fozzie really is fighting against bear intolerance, and Sam the Eagle really, actually is madly in love with Janice. No longer are they, lovable comic actors, they’re now just us.
Maybe it’s not easy to assume the show could fight against these issues when it’s limited by the mockumentary format. Nobody can break out into song, or break the fourth wall that isn’t meant to be there, wryly comment outside of the action. It’s as if somebody took a look at the behind-the-scenes segments of “The Muppet Show” and pondered, “what if we took this seriously, for an adult audience?” This is not what anybody, surely, intended, or even wanted.
This seemed to be the general consensus as critics walked away baffled and the ratings plummeted. The show continued to be tweaked towards a sunnier outlook similar to the content most were familiar with. ABC extended the episode order from 13 to 16 and fired Kushell as an executive producer. Kristen Newman was brought in to drastically retool the show, introducing an antagonist in the form of a scheming network executive and toning down Piggy to be more likable.
The episodes started to grasp a more charming tone as the adult jokes waned, and sketches were introduced on the series. Kermit is seen breaking up with Denise and gravitating back towards Miss Piggy. It was less cynical mockumentary, more “30 Rock with Muppets”.
What the show could’ve eventually evolved into will never be known, as ABC canceled the show in May 2016. Low ratings and budgetary casualties were to blame, and the franchise was once again put on ice. In the half-decade since Steve Whitmire was fired as Kermit the Frog and replaced with the struggling Matt Vogel. We also had a well-liked, but short-lived street show at the Magic Kingdom, a couple of live concert shows, and a rather successful Muppet Babies reboot that sadly does not utilize puppetry at all, opting for CGI.
Next month, Disney+ will be offering the unscripted sketch series “Muppets Now”, the first big project for the franchise involving the puppets themselves since the ill-fated primetime effort. That show was touted by ABC’s president as featuring “not your grandma’s Muppets”. Honestly? I hope “Muppets Now” features my grandmother’s Muppets. They were funnier.
“The Muppets” (2015) is currently available to view on Disney+.
Traveling Salesman is a Columnist for the Boardwalk Times. He’s also a host for the Boardwalk Talk podcast on iTunes.



