Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

‘Monsters at Work’ is a Genuine but Flawed Attempt at Capturing the Magic of Pixar’s Best

‘Monsters at Work’ is funny and charming but is clearly missing the expertise that made the original film a classic.

Disney is no stranger to film-to-television adaptations. During the Disney Renaissance, various cinematic properties saw extended life in the form of a television spin-off which often paled in comparison to the source material. Aladdin is a classic film, but the washed-out colors, simplified animation, and replacements to the performance cast ensured that the television show paled in comparison. Similar things can be said for the television adaptations of Lilo and Stitch, Hercules, and Tarzan, each offering some derivative form of an original film in formats more complementary to episodic television.

Pixar, however, has been far more conservative with its properties. Cars saw a cinematic spinoff with DisneyToon’s Planes in 2013, but not since Buzz Lightyear of Star Command has a Pixar property been translated to episodic television. Created to capitalize on the Toy Story Mania (pun partially intended), the 2D animated show abandoned the film’s groundbreaking 3D art direction to focus more on new characters, and more importantly, new merchandising. Famously disliked by some of Pixar’s higher-ups, the show served the will of corporate Disney in the 90s.

It should be a surprise, then, that Pixar has handed off the sacred Monsters Inc. property to Disney Television Animation to produce somewhat of a sequel series for the streaming platform Disney+. Taking place in between the penultimate and final scene of the original film, Monsters at Work initially confuses with its dedication to a weekly episodic format, though future developments with a misfit cast of characters may yet validate this questionable excursion.

Episode 1: Welcome to Monsters, Incorporated

The series begins right around where the first film starts, following young scarer Tylor Tuskman on his rise to the top at Monsters University. This primes the series for a subtle yet compelling foundation, that is the sudden pivot away from scaring children following the events of the first film. Tylor anticipates greatness on his first day but finds himself woefully unprepared to make anyone laugh. He’s simply not funny, and though Mike Wazowski’s new company comedy classes could remedy his faults, it appears that Monster Incorporated is not all he’d hoped it would be. For now, he’ll have to make do with the Monsters Incorporated Facilities Team (MIFT for short), a rag-tag bunch of misfits that find family in their differences. Tylor must make a choice: does he learn to make people laugh and go against his talents, or abandon his dreams of the scare/laugh floor.

Off the bat, the most noticeable aspect of the show is the decline in animation quality. Sometimes it looks somewhat standard, but throughout most of the first episode, I found myself incredibly dishearted. New characters like Tylor and Roz’s sister Roze are unimaginative and bland, with Tylor in particular looking as if someone drew a human outline, colored it purple, and slapped a boring face at the top. Even with some of the more imaginative designs (I quite like the look of Tylor’s boss Fritz), the lighting engine on display is just plain bad, making characters look flat. Returning designs like Sulley and Mike have never looked worse, with Sulley, in particular, suffering the greatest from the animation changes. The original film was released a decade ago, and somehow that level of animation hasn’t yet trickled down to television, let alone a premium streaming service. Ironically enough, this is the first time any of these monsters have lived up to their terrifying intentions.

apparently, the cameraman forgot his dolly
maybe they wanted to squeeze every penny out of those models
please just zoom in to the talking character

More than anything, the show is visually uninspired. Monsters Inc. not only revolutionized animation with its technology but proved that the medium could balance fantastical worlds, adult themes, and the core tenants of contemporary cinema. Monsters at Work has no visual identity of its own, and to make matters worse, continually shows an ineptitude for dynamic framing. One of the most common shots in the show features the scene’s characters all facing one another for a conversation, idly waiting for the speaker to finish, all while the camera is pulled out to show the entire cast. Notice in the fourth screenshot that the characters barely look as if they’re in front of the factory, standing almost as if they’re on the set of a stage play. This may be a minor nitpick to some, but after the third or fourth time, you begin to realize just how awkward it is to watch the cast’s blank stares as a result of the cinematographer’s disinterest in blocking. Perhaps Disney Television Animation’s prior history in 2D projects led to the use of this cheap framing (something Ryan O’Reilly hypothesized to me earlier), but that begs the question as to why Disney gave the group a project that directly contrasted their area of expertise.

The clear winners of the first episode were the returning cast, and more specifically, a brilliant performance by Billy Crystal. I don’t know how he does it, but two decades later he brings the same energy (if not more) to the character of Mike Wazowski. Goodman feels a bit more subdued this time around, but Crystal nails it so well that this isn’t an issue.

What is an issue, however, is this episode’s odd balance between new and old characters. Scenes jump between a storyline involving Tylor’s acclimation to the new Monsters Inc, as well as a subplot following Sulley and Mike’s early days as managers. The scene breakdown leans more towards the returning cast, which undermines the introduction of new faces. If you want to introduce new characters to an audience, it’s best not to position them as distractions from those they’re already familiar with.

The first episode of Monsters at Work commits the cardinal sin of any reboot: leaving the audience craving more of the original. I found myself wholly disinterested in Tylor’s conflict but dying to get just a minute more of Crystal’s Wazowski. That lingering interest may provide the momentum to bring audiences into the series, but maintaining that attention requires far more than something already perfected at the series inception.

Episode 2: Meet MIFT

one more for good measure (these are real shots, not promo)

Surprisingly, I think episode two addressed many of the complaints I had with the pilot. The old characters are relegated to minor cameo positions, the new characters’ conflict and chemistry were dynamic and interesting, and the pivot towards filler adventures over a structured plot alleviated the necessary weight on the fragile characterization.

Episode two centers around Tylor’s initiation to MIFT, exploring a side of the company unmentioned in the original film. This gives the writing team a bit more creative freedom, allowing for brand new storylines that better fit the main character’s conflict. I will admit that the moment I saw a kid escape from a door I had a moment of panic over the possibility of retreading the original film, though that bit was only a momentary excuse for character development.

This episode may not have been significant to some overarching plot, but as an episodic office comedy centered around the company behind the popular scarers, it works decently well! There’s not much more to say about an admittedly underwritten episode, but I found myself mildly surprised at how well they nailed office comedy in a monster-filled world.

Verdict

If a Pixar film is the five-course meal of animation, Monsters at Work is the cheap knock-off sold at the burger chain down the street. It lacks the flavor and quality of Pixar’s own projects but gets it just enough to be a strong budget alternative.

What I fail to understand is exactly why Disney+ feels the need to fill their library with subpar material. For all intents and purposes, Disney is the strongest company in the medium, and yet their own streaming service has yet to get a quality, made-for-streaming, original piece of animation. Consumers anticipated excellence from Disney’s entertainment platform, and yet the original content has failed to live up to the expected quality of a Disney project. Lucasfilm and Marvel Studios have created cinema-level content for the platform, and yet it’s Disney themselves who have seen their content suffer as a result of the focus on streaming. Perhaps animation is a more costly medium than that of live-action, but for a Disney branded streaming service, I assume that many are expecting high-quality, original animated content.

Monsters at Work appears to be no different than the numerous direct-to-video Disney films rotting in the depths of their bottomless vault. It’s funny in parts, and there’s promise in the unique concepts, but the ugly animation will likely turn away viewers more familiar with Pixar’s brilliant character design. It’s not a great show, but it’s an entertaining one, retaining the charm of the original film while offering a different spin on the concept. I find myself cautiously optimistic for the rest of the series, and I hope the future episodes focus more on what’s new instead of faithlessly retreading better media.

Ryan Dorman is a Columnist and the Content Director for the Boardwalk Times. He can be found on Twitter at @OpentheDorman.

Popular Articles