Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

‘Monsters at Work’ Episode 3 Shows Unexpected Promise for an Underrated Series

‘The Damaged Room’ reminds audiences why they fell in love with these characters nearly two decades ago

In my review of the first two episodes of Disney Television Animation’s Monsters at Work, I heavily criticized the show for feeling undeniably cheap and unbearably awkward. First impressions were not kind to the studio’s debut 3D animated series, as the artistic quality paled in comparison to what has been done on other streaming services. After my initial optimism faded, I quickly became confused as to why Disney would even pursue the series under such creative constraints.

Luckily, the show’s third episode reinforces the best aspects of the first two, and though the content rarely comes close to the quality of the source film, audiences will find themselves free of the exposition baggage and charmed by the clear dedication to expanding an already dynamic world.

The Episode

This week’s episode follows a familiar plotline: while the MIFT crew fixes a room damaged by another monster’s acid sneezes, Mike and Sulley are tasked with babysitting the displaced child. Audiences may quickly recognize that this plotline mirrors the 2001 movie, something that was initially offputting after reading the plot summary. The original film nailed the human/monster relationship dynamic, and the story is iconic, and more importantly, untouchable. Reboot series have a tantalizing opportunity to load episodes with callbacks to the original material, but biting the nostalgia apple often leads to a soulless product.

Though the episode does have a few explicit callbacks to the film (the Boo debacle, a stage-play excuse, Mike and Sulley as parents), the show never tramples over the original film’s legacy. Referential moments are far and few between, giving a chance for the familiar characters to engage in a storyline more original than derivative. When Sulley scores two tickets to the Monstropolis baseball game, Mike brings the child along with him in a manner similar to the disguising of Boo. Rather than harp on Sulley’s emotional relationship with Boo, the episode instead explores Mike’s change of heart following the film’s events. He no longer sees children as an impediment, developing an emotional tie to the baby he’s nicknamed “Snore.” Mike, Sulley, and Snore attend a baseball game, and general hijinks ensue.

Back at Monsters Inc, the MIFT team have locked themselves in Snore’s room after a comedy of errors. Tylor gets annoyed with Val’s constant recollection of college memories he can’t remember, Val reveals that no one talked to her but him (and he did so out of politeness), etc, etc. Sadly, the MIFT crew are, yet again, relegated to a cliche storyline with little depth. It’s mildly captivating, but still, nothing special.

Once the room has been fixed, Mike and Sulley return to Monsters Inc with Snore, and Mike tucks her into bed with a cleverly antagonistic song. Having Billy Crystal spring into a lullaby felt a bit odd, but for a show that had done so little to find an identity, the ending left a bit of the heart that was desperately needed.

The Review

Monsters at Work is not perfect, but the series is on an upward trajectory. The framing is less flat, the characters find themselves in unique situations, and the show has begun to explore areas of both Monsters Inc and Monstropolis that the film never mentioned. The baseball stadium was a great change of pace, carried by Goodman and Crystal’s expert performances. The reuse of the “misplaced child” trope was initially disappointing, but by the end of the episode, enough had been done to distinguish it from the first film before becoming stale.

Even though the Mike and Sulley parts worked, the MIFT crew still have yet to prove worthy of attention. Choosing to bring back the film’s cast was a great way to expand upon the film’s narrative, but it also created an imbalance in quality across the series. Most shows abandon the original narrative in the first episode not only because it would be expensive to hire these actors fully, but because the creative team needs to show confidence and commitment towards these new characters. Tylor may be a decent enough character, but when the other scenes feature two phenomenal performances of characters audiences are already acquainted with, most will find themselves passively engaging with the unfamiliar. It feels like DTVA were not confident enough in their new characters to create a wholly isolated show with them, but failed to appreciate how stifling the returning cast would be.

That being said, I quite enjoyed this week’s episode. The humor is still charming, the animation looks much better, and the scenarios allowed for great worldbuilding and comedy. The show is still nothing special, and I’m beginning to question the decision to de-emphasize the new characters, but there’s certainly good reason to be optimistic for the rest of the season.

Ryan Dorman is a Columnist and the Content Director for the Boardwalk Times. He can be found on Twitter at @OpentheDorman.

Popular Articles