An excerpt from our September newsletter. You can subscribe here.
After incredible ratings, massive critical acclaim, and a slew of awards, the entire industry seems to be befuddled by the fact that Disney hasn’t ordered a revival series of The Muppet Show. It’s truly a baffling mystery. The backdoor pilot of The Muppet Show starring Sabrina Carpenter was universally beloved.
Now rumblings have emerged that Disney, Seth Rogen’s Point Grey Pictures, and The Muppets Studio can’t agree on a premise for a series. Which leads me to believe there has to be more to the story because that excuse is unbelievably dumb. There has to be larger creative disagreements or budgeting issues; truly, anything is better than “we can’t come to an agreement on a premise of a show that has had a premise that has worked since 1976!”
It’s laughable because The Muppet Show backdoor pilot set the revival up so well. The Muppet Show has always been episodic, but the backdoor pilot did give Kermit the Frog some moments of doubt where he questioned whether The Muppets still had it and if they could still pull off the show. The special ended with The Muppets triumphantly singing “Don’t Stop Us Now” by Queen and declaring “we’re so back.”
Point Grey is working on multiple projects at Disney, including Darkwing Duck, which they figured out a premise for! This isn’t rocket science. I have also seen people jump and assert blame on certain parties. We truly don’t know what caused this brutal, momentum-stalling stalemate for a franchise that desperately needs to be utilized. The Muppets are an ideal flywheel franchise for Disney. The Muppets move merch, they are featured in the Disney Parks, and in an ideal world they should have a presence on Disney+ and at Walt Disney Studios for film projects.
What is the holdup? I truly suspect there is more to the story, and I suspect it is about the creative and budget. I don’t buy the “premise” excuse. The Muppet Show special provided a path forward. I don’t want to see The Muppets in a project like Muppets Now — a bizarre pandemic-era, TikTok-brain “unscripted” series — ever again. Does Disney not want to shell out the money for A-list guests on the caliber of Sabrina Carpenter? Disney doesn’t want to pay Olivia Rodrigo, Ryan Gosling, Florence Pugh, Robert Downey Jr., etc. to hang out with The Muppets? What are the current motives of the leadership at The Muppets Studio? Is Point Grey interested in doing more work with The Muppets Studio? Why hasn’t The Muppets Studio been moved under Walt Disney Studios instead of Walt Disney Imagineering/Disney Live Entertainment?
Another factor that makes Disney’s Muppet Mystery so bizarre is that it was heavily rumored at the beginning of the year that the team behind The Muppet Show special was working on additional episodes. Now, if that was the case, it also undermines the current story of the parties involved not being able to figure out a premise. They clearly figured something out if they were writing additional episodes. It truly doesn’t make sense what the holdup could be.
It’s a bummer how this all played out. The special was a success across the board, and Disney had opportunities to announce additional episodes at D23: The Ultimate Disney Fan Event or during September, which featured key Muppet dates like the 50th anniversary of The Muppet Show and Jim Henson’s birthday. It just feels like a major missed opportunity. I truly hope the next time I write about The Muppets it’s for good news.
Support Boardwalk Times
Be sure to follow Boardwalk Times for more coverage of The Walt Disney Company.
Zach Perilstein is the Editor-in-Chief of the Boardwalk Times



