A special excerpt from our June newsletter. You can subscribe here.
Elemental was an amazing film. It felt like classic Pixar. It had vibrant animation, fun characters, and a solid overall theme. Despite Elemental being beloved by critics and fans, the film only made $29.5 million at the box office. That’s the lowest in the history of Pixar.
Disney’s marketing efforts for Elemental weren’t great.
It’s quite evident that the general audience didn’t even realize Elemental was coming out until it was too late. At points, it felt like Disney wasn’t even trying to market Elemental to a mass audience. Someone, somewhere within Disney decided to give The Little Mermaid (a film that is a remake that sells itself) the full marketing blitz while ignoring Pixar.
To make matters worse, Elemental’s low opening is coming at a time when Pixar just can’t find itself a win. Onward was released at the beginning of the pandemic. During the Chapek era, we witnessed three Pixar films sent directly to Disney+. The pandemic was happening, so releasing Soul direct to Disney+ made sense at the time. Luca should’ve gone to theaters. Even if it would’ve opened lower, it would’ve kept Pixar’s theatrical brand intact. Heck, Turning Red which came out in 2022 should’ve been in theaters. (If Disney was concerned about how the film would’ve performed against The Batman, they could’ve just taken the hit and delayed it. That’s better than just giving it away for essentially “free”).
After the three straight-to-Disney+ films, Pixar returned to theaters with a Toy Story spinoff Lightyear. The film was a big financial and creative misfire (I won’t stick Lightyear’s failure on Disney at all, that was a pure Pixar move and even the best of studios sometimes miss). Yet, Disney’s lack of Elemental marketing is just another example of how Disney has mistreated one of its most prized and beloved studios.
So it’s time to ask: Is Disney Failing Pixar?
Sure, Pixar films have been theatrical since its existence but did the whole “Pixar to Disney+” strategy screw up Pixar’s audience? This quote from Pixar CCO Pete Docter expresses how that strategy was a mixed blessing.
“In the long run, there’s been a bit of a mixed blessing because we’ve trained audiences that these films will be available for you on Disney+. And it’s more expensive for a family of four to go to a theater when they know they can wait and it’ll come out on the platform.”
Animation is for everyone, but one of Pixar’s core audiences is families. Docter makes an excellent point that it’s cheaper for families to watch on Disney+ than to go to the theater. So, it may be safe to assume that some families are just fine waiting 40 days to see Lightyear or Elemental show up on Disney+, after all these same families got to watch Soul, Luca, and Turning Red for free with their Disney+ subscriptions. It may be a hard habit for families to break.
Docter continued to share his views on why families are reluctant to return in his interview with Variety:
“I think families with kids are more reluctant. It’s not just health, it’s the cost. It’s not a cheap outing to go to the theater and buy popcorn. It’s a great time, but they really are very selective about what they’re going to go see.”
The problem is in the last line of this quote. Families are selective about what they’re going to go see. Sure it’s harder to get people to go along for the ride and see something original but you still have to try. You also have to market the movie! Sure, Across the Spider-Verse and Super Mario Bros. Movie had huge fanbases already baked in but those films did their fair share of marketing in the lead-up to their releases. (Mario is the highest-grossing film of 2023 so far, Spider-Verse is fourth!)
Docter mentioned how people want comfort of what they know but he also said how it’s essential that all the studios continue to develop new original stories. Docter admitted it’s harder to get people excited and harder to publicize. Pixar makes some of the most creative films in the world, maybe it’s time for them — along with Disney — to get creative with their promotion. But we can’t forget at one point all Pixar titles were originals!
Then Disney decided to trot Elemental and Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny at Cannes. Just a bizarre decision in hindsight for BOTH films. Heck, Pete Docter even said the Cannes premiere was confusing. Elemental went from a seven-minute standing ovation to being torn to shreds and being stuck with a bad Rotten Tomatoes score. The Rotten Tomatoes score would rise once more reviews got in.
Elemental just seems like another case of Disney neglecting Pixar for no good reason. And this time the world can’t blame it on Chapek!
But now let’s look at the other side of the coin: Is Pixar failing Disney?
This seems like a case that is being made everywhere. So I have to explore it, and I know I’m writing about how Disney is failing Pixar but one knock against the studio is the sheer fact that not every single film should cost $200M. Animators and animation are expensive but when every film costs $200M, it’s a lot tougher financially when you miss.
After the box office bomb of Lightyear, Disney actually increased its oversight at Pixar. When you start to lose money you start to lose your autonomy and freedom. Pixar has to address the large budgets because their competitors make their films at a way lower cost.
Another issue, that has been discussed when debating this Pixar situation is the fact original animation may be too tough to sell in this current environment. We mentioned this a ton in the previous section on how it’s difficult to market original films. We also have to consider the fact that Pixar as a studio has grown up a bit. It’s a different studio now than it was back when it was run by Ed Catmull and John Lasseter. Pixar has more fresh and diverse voices than ever and that’s a good thing. All studios evolve but maybe Pixar being a more mature and ambitious studio is actually hurting its appeal with the kids and family demographic. Just a thought as that point has been argued.
Pixar CCO Pete Docter has gone on the record that Pixar doesn’t make programming for children. Of course, Pixar makes programming for everyone. However, Matt Belloni of Puck News reported that one Pixar insider believes that Pixar has lost its broad accessibility.
I don’t think we should be going after Docter though. He shouldn’t be blamed for all these chaotic circumstances that were largely out of his control. His track record since taking over Pixar has been good critically. It should be better commercially but he can only control what he can control, and that’s telling good stories.
Pixar’s future is uncertain for the most part. We may have to dive into its future in a future newsletter. However we got Win or Lose, Pixar’s first long-form Disney+ series coming out this year. An Inside Out Disney+ series is also in the works, and likely will be long-form if I had to guess. Pixar’s 2024 film slate is Elio, which only has a teaser so far but it’s giving me Lightyear vibes… Then we got Inside Out 2 happening but it’s unclear if the entire voice cast will return. I think this sequel will only work if they can get the entire crew back. You don’t want a Pixar sequel coming across as a direct-to-VHS-type film.
Elemental thankfully only dropped 37% in its second weekend and had a $18 million haul. Word of mouth works, and the film deserves it. Although that opening could’ve been a lot stronger if Disney didn’t putz around and actually advertised it.
I personally think Disney is failing Pixar by not giving it the right marketing support. Instead of just making Toy Story 5, there should be some deep discussions on how to improve the marketing and promotion of future Pixar original films. Disney should also try to boost the morale at Pixar. Heck, maybe give Soul, Luca, and Turning Red limited one-weekend runs at the box office during the slow months at the theaters?
Either way, Disney has to figure out its situation with Pixar before it is too late.
Be sure to continue to follow Boardwalk Times for more coverage of The Walt Disney Company.
Support Boardwalk Times on Ko-Fi.
Support Boardwalk Times by shopping on Boardwalk Store:
If you like this article. Subscribe to my free newsletter Boardwalk Times: Stories from the Seashore, a monthly dose of Disney, its businesses, and the wider themed entertainment industry.
Zach Perilstein is the Editor-in-Chief of the Boardwalk Times



